I Love New York Pizza: Authentic NY Style Pizza in Chapel Hill
I Love New York Pizza, located at 106 W Franklin St, Chapel Hill, NC, is a beloved eatery known for its authentic NYC-style pizza. Family-owned and operating for over two decades, this iconic spot serves massive, thin slices that resonate with locals and newcomers alike. Customers rave about the warm, friendly atmosphere and quick service, making it a perfect late-night stop. Each slice is generously sized and packed with flavor, often leaving patrons yearning for more. While prices are reflective of current food costs, the quality and experience make every bite worthwhile. It's truly a destination for pizza lovers.
Photos & Gallery
Popular Menu Items
N Y Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Roma Spinach Pizza
Ham and Pineapple
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
I Love New York Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
The vibe was authentic pizza spot, the gentleman in the place was friendly, and the pizza was very good.
Great place to grab NY style pizza. I have been coming to this place since moving from NJ. Quick service and delicious pizza right on Franklin St.
Iconic Chapel Hill restaurant, family owned, been eating here for 20 years, open late and serves classic thin NYC style MONSTER sized slices. Can get super crowded by drunken undergrads late night but you can still get in and out with a great slice or two, or a whole pie. Food costs are brutal right now for small local places so $5 a slice is seemingly high but look at what you get, it's worth it. Eat local.
Absolutely amazing! The atmosphere was cozy, not much room. Food was so good I could have gone back for a second slice, but there was no way I could another! Slices are very generous, and you can definitely make a pizza taco out of it!
Great job and good pizza. Friendly place and the pizza is delicious. Don't mind the other reviews. While this isn't the cheapest pizza its a good one and me and my wife had a great time after our newborn was born :)
Location
-
106 W Franklin St #2516, Chapel Hill, NC 27516, United States Hotline: +1 919-968-4224
Welcome to I Love New York Pizza, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Chapel Hill, North Carolina. Located at 106 W Franklin St #2516, this family-owned establishment has been dishing out classic New York-style pizza for over 20 years, becoming a cherished institution for locals and visitors alike.
The moment you step inside, you’re enveloped in an authentic pizza parlor vibe. The friendly staff makes you feel right at home, ready to serve you their signature thin-crust pizzas that are nothing short of extraordinary. As one satisfied patron, Eric Woods, noted, “The vibe was authentic pizza spot, the gentleman in the place was friendly, and the pizza was very good.” This genuine warmth adds to the entire dining experience.
A frequent customer, Eli515, raves about the convenience and mouthwatering flavors, stating, “Great place to grab NY style pizza.” Whether you're a new guest or a regular from New Jersey, you can count on quick service without sacrificing quality. The slices here are indeed generous, perfect for crafting your very own pizza taco as Shanna Elkins humorously points out after savoring her meal.
One of the main highlights of I Love New York Pizza is its iconic reputation within the community. As Brad Russell points out, "Iconic Chapel Hill restaurant... serves classic thin NYC style MONSTER sized slices." The late-night crowd, often made up of spirited undergrads, gives the place a lively energy, yet the establishment manages to maintain a cozy atmosphere, making it ideal for a quick bite or a late-night feast.
Price-wise, while some might find $5 per slice a bit steep, the quality and sheer size of the offerings make every penny worth it. As Ted Melkoumov notes, “While this isn't the cheapest pizza, it's a good one.” This commitment to quality, in spite of rising food costs, showcases the dedication of I Love New York Pizza to serve the best for its loyal customers.
Whether you're indulging in a slice after a late-night study session or enjoying a whole pie with friends, I Love New York Pizza serves up much more than just food; it offers a slice of community and warmth that makes every visit special. Don’t miss out on this Chapel Hill icon! Call them at +1 919-968-4224 to learn more or place an order. You won’t regret your choice to eat local and support this delightful eatery!
- Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
- Service options
- Kerbside pickup
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
- Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards